New brick on a room addition, stained in 2003 to match the original house, reading as one blend at the corner of a Franklin, Indiana home in 2021

Brick & Masonry Staining in Bloomington The New Brick Matches the Old.

Bramwell-McKay stains brick across Bloomington and Monroe County: new and replacement brick matched to the old, patches blended, whole houses recolored. Brushed on by hand and warrantied for life.

Monroe County and south central Indiana

Bloomington houses, rentals and new apartment buildings, matched brick by brick.

Monroe County builds differently from the rest of Indiana. In 2025, 77 percent of the new housing units permitted in the county were in buildings of five units or more, against 29 percent statewide. A house and an apartment building get the same mineral stain and the same written warranty; what differs is who signs off on the color.

Brick staining in Bloomington, Indiana.

Bramwell-McKay does brick staining in Bloomington by hand, with a permanent mineral stain, a written price after a site visit and a lifetime warranty. The crews come out of masonry restoration and work out of an office at 38 W Main St in Carmel, and Bloomington sits well inside the two-hour drive our Indiana crews treat as routine.

The stain is mineral, not paint. Inorganic pigments soak into the masonry and bond with the clay, so the color sits inside the wall instead of forming a film across it. The brick keeps breathing, the texture does not change, and nothing is left on the surface to peel.

Bloomington is the Monroe County seat, a city of about 83,000 people by the Census Bureau's 2025 estimate, and 41.5 percent of the county's housing units are rented, against 26.9 percent across Indiana. Brick here sits beside Indiana limestone on houses, apartment buildings and campus buildings alike. The job this page is mostly about is the simplest one to describe: new brick that does not match the old.

Two workers in hard hats on a suspended platform partway up the brick face of a multi-story building
A Franklin, Indiana home in June 2003, the lighter brick of a new room addition meeting the original wall at a vertical seam, with two strips of white tape across the new courses

Matching new brick to old brick in Bloomington

The documented files closest to Bloomington are in Franklin, Mooresville and Fishers. Each one has its own page with the before photos, the later photos and the signed record, and each is named by the town it is in. How a match is made, step by step, is on brick color matching. Whether to stain the new brick or tear it out, and what each costs, is in stain or tear out mismatched brick.

  • Replacement brick that does not match

    A room addition, a rebuilt wall, a filled opening: the new brick is the right size and the wrong color. On a room addition in Franklin, Indiana, the homeowner had the new brick stained in 2003, some units lightened and some darkened, and the corner still read as one wall in 2021.

  • A repair patch that shows

    Under a window is a hard place for a match to hold, because, in the case file's words, a lot of water catches there. On a Fishers, Indiana home in 2007, a run of brick under the windows sat off color, and the mason who built the wall hired the correction. It still matched its neighbors in 2019. New mortar that stands out is handled the same way: see mortar color correction.

  • Brick that came in too dark or blotchy

    Lightening and leveling depend on the brick. On a Mooresville, Indiana home in 2007, the company that made the brick paid to carry the dark red units to salmon, and the walls still read level in 2019. Builders can start at the builders and contractors page.

  • Limestone next to the brick

    The stain is listed for limestone and natural stone as well as brick, but only where the stone absorbs water. The documented Indiana files are brick, plus one stone addition in Peoria, Indiana, so a limestone patch starts with a water test and a sample before any price.

Brick, block or stone in Bloomington: if it absorbs water, it takes stain

The core of what we do. Any absorbent brick, from an older house near downtown to a new apartment building.

The joints between the brick, stained on their own or along with the wall. New tuckpointing that does not match is covered on mortar color correction.

Concrete block on a garage, a foundation, or an addition takes stain and keeps its texture.

Limestone, sandstone, and fieldstone can be toned, matched, or evened out.

Faded or mismatched veneer stone gets its color back without replacement.

Patio pavers and cast concrete carry color the same way brick does.

Can we get the color you are looking for?

Almost certainly. Colors are custom mixed, so you are not picking from a little fan of chips.

Darker and richer is easy; going much lighter depends on your brick, and we will tell you straight after we see it. Start at brick stain colors to see what is possible.

Three Indiana files, photographed 12 to 18 years later.

How do you know a match holds through Indiana winters? Each of these was stained between 2003 and 2007 and photographed again years later. They are in Franklin, Mooresville and Fishers, not Bloomington, and the signed record is on every case page.

The corner of a Fishers, Indiana home in 2019 seen past the lawn, the repaired brick under the window sill reading as one range with the wall

Thinking about painting your Bloomington brick?

Paint is the quick answer people find when they want brick in a different color, and on a masonry wall it is the expensive one. The City of Bloomington's own design guidelines for the Elm Heights historic district say painting masonry and stone "reduces breathability of the material and initiates a frustrating cycle of maintenance involving scraping, sandblasting, sealing, and repainting" (opens in a new tab).

Mineral stain is absorbed rather than laid on top. The pigment is inorganic and bonds into the pores of the brick, so a hard Indiana winter finds no film to blister or lift. The Brick Industry Association's Technical Note 6, revised in March 2025, says mineral-based stains are "preferred due to their high water vapor permeability" (opens in a new tab).

Painting a brick house usually runs $8,000 to $15,000 and then needs a repaint every 5 to 10 years at $5,000 to $10,000 a round. A whole-home stain runs $15,000 to $30,000 once, with a lifetime warranty on the stain system as applied that excludes mortar deterioration and is voided by a sealer put over it later. Compare both on brick staining vs painting, or, if paint is already lifting, read paint peeling off brick.

Staining vs Painting, in Full

Don't take it from us.

Brick, Indiana limestone, and the city's own review.

Bloomington sits in the Bloomington-Bedford limestone district. An Indiana Geological Survey paper (opens in a new tab) counted more than 100 buildings on the Indiana University Bloomington campus built of limestone from the district, along with countless homes and commercial buildings in Bloomington and Bedford. The city's Elm Heights guidelines describe brick homes with limestone or wood details as well represented there. The same guidelines call limestone soft and absorbent, not to be cleaned the way brick is, which is why stone always gets a water test and a sample first.

If a house is in one of Bloomington's local historic districts, such as Elm Heights, Greater Prospect Hill, Matlock Heights, Maple Heights, McDoel Gardens or the Near West Side, any external change needs a Certificate of Appropriateness (opens in a new tab) from the Historic Preservation Commission before work starts. The Elm Heights guidelines call painting or waterproof-coating exposed masonry not appropriate. Whether a stain is approved is the commission's decision, so talk to the city's Historic Preservation Program Manager at 812-349-3507 before the color is settled.

Work around Bloomington reaches Ellettsville, Bedford, Martinsville, Spencer and Nashville, IN. Projects further south, such as Jasper, are quoted case by case. Every color is mixed for the building and approved on a sample of its own wall first, and the full list of towns is on the service areas page.

The garage end of an Evansville, Indiana home in 2019, its brick one variegated tan and brown range around a window beside the garage door

What to expect when you work with us

  1. Consultation

    We take the brief on the first call: the building, its condition, the result you want, and the schedule the work has to fit.

    You receive Documented scope
  2. Site assessment

    We evaluate the masonry in person. Substrate condition, existing coatings, access, and how the work has to be sequenced around you.

    You receive Condition and access review
  3. Absorption test

    Water on the brick shows how the surface absorbs. Stain bonds into the pore structure, so this result governs whether the substrate qualifies at all.

    You receive Substrate go or no go
  4. Sample panel and proposal

    A section of your actual wall, stained and adjusted until the color is approved. It becomes the reference standard. Firm pricing in writing at the same time.

    You receive Approved color standard, firm written price
  5. Application and closeout

    Applied by hand with a brush, signed off section by section against the approved panel. Final walk, photo documentation, warranty in writing.

    You receive Documented completion, lifetime warranty

Bloomington brick staining questions

Who does brick staining in Bloomington?

Bramwell-McKay does, from an office at 38 W Main St in Carmel; Bloomington and Monroe County sit inside the two-hour drive our Indiana crews treat as routine. A painter coats brick and a mason replaces it; a stainer changes its color with a mineral stain that soaks in. Every price follows a site visit.

Can new brick be stained to match old brick?

Usually, when the new brick is close in size and texture. The new units are stained toward the old, some lightened and some darkened, so nothing has to come out. A room addition in Franklin, Indiana was matched that way in 2003 and still read as one wall when it was photographed again in 2021.

What does brick staining cost in Bloomington?

The same as anywhere else in Indiana. A whole-home color change usually runs $15,000 to $30,000, and smaller work such as repair matching or a patch is commonly $400 to $8,000. The written price follows a site visit and a sample on your own wall. Whether it pays off is weighed in is brick staining worth it.

Should I paint my brick or stain it?

We would not. Paint sits on the face of the brick and needs redoing every 5 to 10 years at $5,000 to $10,000 a round, and the city's own Elm Heights guidelines tie painted masonry to scraping, sandblasting, sealing and repainting. Stain soaks in, leaves the brick breathable and carries a lifetime warranty.

Can you stain limestone?

The stain is listed for limestone and natural stone as well as brick, but only where the stone absorbs water and carries no sealer or coating. Limestone is soft and absorbent, so a patch or a replacement stone gets a water test and a sample first, and the price follows the sample.

My new tuckpointing doesn't match. Can the mortar be stained?

Usually. Mortar takes mineral stain the way brick does, so new joints can be brought toward the old ones. On a Fishers, Indiana repair in 1998, off color joints and too-dark replacement brick were both lightened, and both still held their range in 2019. See mortar color correction.

My house is in a Bloomington historic district. Can I stain it?

Ask the city first. Any external change to a protected structure in a local historic district needs a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Historic Preservation Commission, and there is no fee to apply. A stained sample panel gives the commission something concrete to review. Approval is their decision, not ours.

Will stain stop water getting into my brick?

No, and it is not meant to. Mineral stain changes the color and leaves the brick breathable; it does not seal or waterproof it. If water is getting in through cracked units or open mortar joints, that is repaired first, and the stain goes on once the wall is sound and dry.

Which towns near Bloomington do you cover?

Bloomington and the rest of Monroe County, including Ellettsville, plus Bedford, Martinsville, Spencer and Nashville, IN. Projects further south, such as Jasper, are quoted case by case. There are separate pages for Indianapolis and Carmel, and every town is on the service areas page.

See your masonry in a new color

Two ways to reach us, and both go straight to a real person. We usually get back to you the same day.

Project Details

Fill out the form

The form asks for what a real quote needs: the address, what the brick looks like now, and photos or drawings of the wall. Fill it out once, and we come out already knowing the job.

Request a Quote
Direct Line

Call us

866-841-1178

A real person answers, and if we are on a wall, we call you right back. Best for a quick question, or if you've never explored stain before and want the full tutorial, we're happy to have a real person call and talk it through with you.

  • Where we work

    Brick staining across Bloomington and Monroe County, Ellettsville, Bedford, Martinsville, Spencer and Nashville, IN, from our office at 38 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032. See all service areas

  • What happens next

    We call you, ask a few questions, and set a visit within days. The water test takes one minute and tells us everything.

  • Architects and builders

    Specifications, warranty language, and product documentation are ready before you ask. Spec sheets and downloads

Call Us Request a Quote