Brick Color Matching for Replacement Brick, Repairs and Additions

When replacement brick, a repair patch or an addition does not match the wall around it, the new brick can be stained to match the old. The color is mixed on site, tried on your own wall and approved there before the rest is stained. Nothing is torn out, the mortar stays in place, and the match is covered by a lifetime warranty.

Why doesn't the new brick match?

Usually because the brick it sits beside is no longer made. On a building of any age the original brick is often out of production, so the mason lays the closest brick available, and the difference shows from the street.

Sometimes the brick is new and still comes out wrong. Two production runs of the same brick can differ, a distributor can deliver pallets that do not match the rest of the house, and a multicolor blend laid unevenly reads as patches instead of a range. Matching production runs and correcting badly blended brick are both on the Brick Industry Association's list of accepted uses for brick stain.

Home exterior where a patch of new replacement brick stands out bright red against the original dark brown wall
Before. One of our jobs: a repair left new brick bright red against a dark brown wall.
The same wall after brick staining, the replacement patch blended in with no visible outline
After. We stained the patch into the original masonry.

Which jobs need a color match?

  • Replacement brick after damage. A corner struck by a car, cracked or spalled units cut out and replaced. On a South Bend house hit by a car, the rebuilt corner now reads as the same wall.
  • Repair patches and rebuilt sections. A wall section relaid after a repair, a rebuilt front wall, a run of brick under the windows.
  • Additions. A new room, wing or story built against an older wall. The match works in either direction: the new brick stained to the old, or the old toned toward the new.
  • Infill. Windows and doors bricked in during a renovation, like the infill on an Indiana elementary school.
  • Chimney rebuilds. A chimney repaired in brick that no longer matches the house, like this rebuilt chimney on an Iowa home.
  • Lower walls and foundations. Brick replaced near the ground, where the new units show above grade.

Stain the new brick, or tear it out?

Stain it, when the replacement brick is the right size and texture and only the color is wrong. Tearing brick out and laying it again runs from a couple thousand dollars and a day's work to weeks of labor and tens of thousands, depending on how big the problem is. Staining the same problem usually costs about a tenth of that, or less. It also leaves the existing mortar in place, which the Brick Industry Association notes is often preferable to removing and replacing individual units or small areas of brickwork. For builders and owners weighing the two, stain or tear out mismatched brick covers who usually pays and when tear-out is still the right call.

Stain changes color. It cannot change a brick's size or surface texture, so if the replacement units are badly off in either, the better fix is the right brick. When you are choosing replacement brick, match the size and texture and leave the color to us. If the original brick is still made, use it, and you may not need us at all. The full matching method, step by step, is on our brick stain colors page.

What does brick color matching cost?

Most corrections, repair patches and addition matches run $400 to $8,000, depending on how much wall is involved and how many coats the color takes. One recent job: a brick distributor delivered pallets that did not match the rest of a home, and the new section came out patchy. We matched it to the existing brick in one day, for about $5,000. What moves the price most is time on the wall, set by the number of coats and how many colors the match has to reproduce. You get a firm price in writing before we start, and the brick staining cost guide has five real job prices.

Is the match permanent?

Yes. Mineral stain soaks into the brick instead of forming a film, so it does not fade or peel, and a matched repair stays matched. Every Bramwell-McKay staining project is covered by a lifetime warranty on workmanship and materials, for the life of the masonry, delivered in writing when the job is done. The stain we apply is made by Masonry Cosmetics, and the warranty terms are published in full.

Who calls us for a match?

Homeowners, after a repair or an addition. Masons and builders, when their new work stands out before a closing. Brick distributors and manufacturers, when a delivery went into the wall off color. Who pays depends on the arrangement between them, and a match on the wall usually ends the argument over whose fault it was. Builders working to a deadline can see how we handle color fixes for builders and contractors.

If it is the joints around the new brick that stand out, that is mortar color correction, and it is often done in the same visit. We work from Carmel across Indiana, including brick staining in Indianapolis, Carmel and Bloomington.

How a color match runs

  1. Send photos

    Close-ups of the new brick, and one shot of the whole wall.

    You receive A first read on the match
  2. Let it cure

    About 30 days after the masonry work, so the wall shows its true color.

    You receive A start date
  3. The water test

    A minute of water on the brick tells us it will take stain.

    You receive Substrate go or no go
  4. Match on the wall

    The color is mixed on site and tried on your wall, coat by coat, until you approve it.

    You receive Approved color, firm written price
  5. Stain the run

    Brushed into the new brick by hand, then walked with you.

    You receive Lifetime warranty, in writing

Brick Color Matching, Asked and Answered

Can new brick be stained to match old brick?

Yes. The color is mixed on site and tuned against the existing wall, coat by coat, until the new brick reads as part of the old. You approve the match on the wall before the rest is stained.

How long after a repair should we wait to stain?

About 30 days after the masonry work. That is our rule of thumb for staining any new masonry, and it gives the new mortar time to cure to its true color.

What if the replacement brick is a different size or texture?

Stain changes color only. It cannot change a brick's size or surface texture, so replacement brick should be chosen to match those, with the color left to the stain. If the size or texture is badly off, relaying with the right brick is the better fix.

Is staining cheaper than tearing out mismatched brick?

Usually by a wide margin. Tearing brick out and laying it again runs from a couple thousand dollars and a day's work to weeks of labor and tens of thousands. Staining the same problem usually costs about a tenth of that, or less.

What does brick color matching cost?

Most corrections, repair patches and addition matches run $400 to $8,000, depending on area and coats. One recent off-color delivery on a home was matched to the existing brick in one day for about $5,000.

Will the match fade or shift later?

No. Mineral stain becomes part of the brick and does not fade or peel, so a matched repair stays matched. It is covered by a lifetime warranty.

Can you match the mortar too?

Yes. Mortar joints can be stained on their own or along with the brick, darker or lighter, so the joints around a repair read the same as the rest of the wall.

Send Us the Wall That Doesn't Match

Photos of the new brick and the wall around it are enough to start. A price comes back in writing.

Request a Quote
Call Us Request a Quote